Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
- BigWave96744
- Moderator
- Posts: 23277
- Joined: Thu Dec 04, 2003 4:37 pm
Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
If you are comfortable with Cole McDonald or Larry Tuileta being in the running for a starting position please don't waste your time reading the rest of this post.
Currently in spring camp we have
True Frosh Jeremy Moussa - High Upside
Soph to be Cole McDonald - 5-19 22 yards 1 TD, but rumored to possibly switch positions
Senior to be Larry Tuileta - last games played was the State Championship game in December 2013, current part time football and volleyball player
Summer
Chevan Coreiro arrives - High Upside
This pretty much leaves us with 2 True Freshman QB in the fall 2018 and no solid backup.
Should someone get hurt or if their adjustment to D1 play is not quite ready, we are in a real bind.
Signing a D1 Transfer with 1 year remaining could serve as an insurance policy.
If they win the starting job, the 2 True Frosh still could redshirt, learn the system and be poised for 4 years
If a True Frosh wins the job, the D1 transfer is still a solid backup along with the other True Frosh.
YES, it didn't quite work out for Norm Chow, but look at what Baker Mayfield did for Oklahoma, and Marcus McMaryion for Fresno St.
Many BCS Schools are picking up grad transfer QBs for 2018.
I'm going to keep track of Grad Transfer QB and if they are available.
Currently in spring camp we have
True Frosh Jeremy Moussa - High Upside
Soph to be Cole McDonald - 5-19 22 yards 1 TD, but rumored to possibly switch positions
Senior to be Larry Tuileta - last games played was the State Championship game in December 2013, current part time football and volleyball player
Summer
Chevan Coreiro arrives - High Upside
This pretty much leaves us with 2 True Freshman QB in the fall 2018 and no solid backup.
Should someone get hurt or if their adjustment to D1 play is not quite ready, we are in a real bind.
Signing a D1 Transfer with 1 year remaining could serve as an insurance policy.
If they win the starting job, the 2 True Frosh still could redshirt, learn the system and be poised for 4 years
If a True Frosh wins the job, the D1 transfer is still a solid backup along with the other True Frosh.
YES, it didn't quite work out for Norm Chow, but look at what Baker Mayfield did for Oklahoma, and Marcus McMaryion for Fresno St.
Many BCS Schools are picking up grad transfer QBs for 2018.
I'm going to keep track of Grad Transfer QB and if they are available.
- BigWave96744
- Moderator
- Posts: 23277
- Joined: Thu Dec 04, 2003 4:37 pm
Re: Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
Code: Select all
QBs who can play immediately
Player HS* Prev School New School Gms/Starts Elig Comments
----------------- --- --------------- ------------ ---------- ---- ------------------------
Drew Barker 4* Kentucky 12 / 5 1 Opted to retire from football in 2018
Ryan Boyle 3* Iowa 0 / 0 2
Keller Chryst 4* Stanford 23 / 6 1
J.J. Cosentino 4* Florida St 12 / 0 1
Quinten Dormandy 4* Tennesse 16 / 5 2 shoulder surgery 2017
Jeff George, Jr 2* Illinois 11 / 8 2
Tucker Israel 3* Clemson 2 / 0 2
Alex Malzone 4* Michigan Miami-Ohio 3 / 0 1 played against Hawaii
James Morgan 3* Bowling Green Florida Int 19 / 10 2
Jalan McClendon 3* North Carolina 18 / 0 1
Shea Patterson 5* Ole Miss Michigan 10 / 10 2
KJ Carta-Samuels 4* Washington UCLA 25 / 1 1
Lindsey Scott 3* LSU/EMCC Missouri 3
Evan Shirreffs 2* Miami 5 / 0 2
Wilton Spieght 3* Michigan 21 / 17 1 back injury in 2017
Alex Thompson NR Wagner 24 / 22 1 NFL Prospect
Darius Wade 3* Boston College Delaware 17 / 3 1
Brady White 4* Arizona St Memphis 2 / 1 2
Sean White 4* Auburn 18 / 16 1
Tyler Wiegers 4* Iowa E. Michigan 6 / 0 1
QBs who could transfer and play immediately
Joe Burrow 4* Ohio State 11 / 0 2
Brandon Dawkins 3* Arizona 23 / 9 1 born in Hawaii
Tommy Stevens 3* Penn St 14 / 0 2
Jordan Ta'amu 3* Ole Miss 8 / 0 1 Pearl City HS Grad
-
- Hall of famer
- Posts: 2467
- Joined: Mon Apr 25, 2011 3:40 pm
Re: Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
The two transfers QBs you named aren’t one and done players. Not even grad transfers.BigWave96744 wrote: ↑Mon Jan 22, 2018 10:49 pm If you are comfortable with Cole McDonald or Larry Tuileta being in the running for a starting position please don't waste your time reading the rest of this post.
Currently in spring camp we have
True Frosh Jeremy Moussa - High Upside
Soph to be Cole McDonald - 5-19 22 yards 1 TD, but rumored to possibly switch positions
Senior to be Larry Tuileta - last games played was the State Championship game in December 2013, current part time football and volleyball player
Summer
Chevan Coreiro arrives - High Upside
This pretty much leaves us with 2 True Freshman QB in the fall 2018 and no solid backup.
Should someone get hurt or if their adjustment to D1 play is not quite ready, we are in a real bind.
Signing a D1 Transfer with 1 year remaining could serve as an insurance policy.
If they win the starting job, the 2 True Frosh still could redshirt, learn the system and be poised for 4 years
If a True Frosh wins the job, the D1 transfer is still a solid backup along with the other True Frosh.
YES, it didn't quite work out for Norm Chow, but look at what Baker Mayfield did for Oklahoma, and Marcus McMaryion for Fresno St.
Many BCS Schools are picking up grad transfer QBs for 2018.
I'm going to keep track of Grad Transfer QB and if they are available.
Baker Mayfield was a sophomore with a redshirt to burn for his transfer year when he went to Oklahoma. Not quite the same as one and done.
Marcus McMaryion came to Fresno St as junior using his redshirt for his transfer year.
-
- Hall of famer
- Posts: 2467
- Joined: Mon Apr 25, 2011 3:40 pm
Re: Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
Keller Chryst
Jeff George J.R.
Are notable grad transfers that if I were Rolo I would consider.
One “not” grad transfer I would like is Shane Buechele from Texas.
Jeff George J.R.
Are notable grad transfers that if I were Rolo I would consider.
One “not” grad transfer I would like is Shane Buechele from Texas.
- BigWave96744
- Moderator
- Posts: 23277
- Joined: Thu Dec 04, 2003 4:37 pm
Re: Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
http://www.visaliatimesdelta.com/story/ ... 752012001/After graduating from Oregon State with a degree in public health this past summer, and missing a sense of community, McMaryion had an opportunity to transfer.
There was one school on top of his list: Fresno State.
In early August, McMaryion officially joined the Bulldogs as a graduate transfer.
- BigWave96744
- Moderator
- Posts: 23277
- Joined: Thu Dec 04, 2003 4:37 pm
Re: Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
Would be funny if upon finishing college, June Jones signs Jeff George, Jr to play in the CFLEITSwarrior wrote: ↑Tue Jan 23, 2018 12:13 am Keller Chryst
Jeff George J.R.
Are notable grad transfers that if I were Rolo I would consider.
One “not” grad transfer I would like is Shane Buechele from Texas.
Link
Go to 1:22:30
- Irse
- Moderator
- Posts: 14100
- Joined: Sat Jun 26, 2004 8:06 pm
- MLB: Cubs
- NFL: Cowboys
- Location: Mililani, HI
Re: Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
Maybe it'll be ok but it usually takes at least a year for the QB to get comfortable with the RnS. Look at Junes' record when he had to break in a new QB, all losing seasons except for the first one. If the pattern follows and we are struggling this year, I would rather struggle with a QB that will be around a few years and not with someone who will leave after the year and we'll have to have a new QB again next year.
Re: Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
Ta'amu is intriguing, but I've grown tired of transfers, JC or not. I'm ready for UH to organically develop a QB for once. If we're gonna lose, let's build towards something.
- BigWave96744
- Moderator
- Posts: 23277
- Joined: Thu Dec 04, 2003 4:37 pm
Re: Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
True but the last HS QB that was developed by Hawaii and finished as a starter? Was Timmy Chang. Ikaika Woolsey got replaced by Dru his senior year.
JC transfers who finished their senior year strong
Dan Robinson, Rolo, Colt, Greg Alexander, Bryant Moniz, Shane Austin
I thought Aaron Zwalen was going to break that string. Moussa and Cordeiro has huge upsides but of they aren't ready, who we go as a backup?
- cabanalane
- All-American
- Posts: 1997
- Joined: Tue Nov 12, 2013 12:17 pm
- Location: I stay on the mainland
Re: Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
I like OP's idea. Get a one-and-done. Establish the receivers, line, etc. Then bring in the fresh QB. He will have a much easier time to grow, learn, and build up the confidence.
Plug in the QB last. But get him first. Red shirt and learn.
The only down side is Rolo is in his 3rd year. But I think fans are giving him a longer leash. Fire Chow came in the 3rd year. But that may be Chow reluctant to do anything new. Rolo is changing the offense. I think fans will give him more time. Today's fans are different I think. This 3rd year can not be like the 2nd year or fans will start chanting...
Plug in the QB last. But get him first. Red shirt and learn.
The only down side is Rolo is in his 3rd year. But I think fans are giving him a longer leash. Fire Chow came in the 3rd year. But that may be Chow reluctant to do anything new. Rolo is changing the offense. I think fans will give him more time. Today's fans are different I think. This 3rd year can not be like the 2nd year or fans will start chanting...
-
- Hall of famer
- Posts: 2467
- Joined: Mon Apr 25, 2011 3:40 pm
Re: Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
Ok, but he’s not a one and doneBigWave96744 wrote: ↑Tue Jan 23, 2018 1:24 amhttp://www.visaliatimesdelta.com/story/ ... 752012001/After graduating from Oregon State with a degree in public health this past summer, and missing a sense of community, McMaryion had an opportunity to transfer.
There was one school on top of his list: Fresno State.
In early August, McMaryion officially joined the Bulldogs as a graduate transfer.
Re: Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
Well whoever the qb is going to be better be tough. I really don’t know what to expect when it comes to our oline. In the R&S our opponents will be looking to rush and destroy our quarterback. If our oline is not ready the new quarterback will get pounded. We will also need a really good blocking back who can run.
Not doubting, not hating, not loving, just hoping because I am a fan.
“WELCOME HOME COACH” Go get’em Timmy
“WELCOME HOME COACH” Go get’em Timmy
- stranger808
- All-conference
- Posts: 1390
- Joined: Sat Aug 06, 2016 9:33 am
- MLB: Rangers
- NBA: Clippers
Re: Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
we need more arms for practice. four QB's are not enough.
- BigWave96744
- Moderator
- Posts: 23277
- Joined: Thu Dec 04, 2003 4:37 pm
Re: Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
Recruiting 3 QB in a given year happen often in a passing offense
2000: Timmy Chang (HS), Kevin Gilbride (BYU Transfer), Nick Rolovich (JC)
2002: Inoke Funaki (HS), Ryan Stickler (HS), Jason Weildon (JC)
2004: Tyler Graunke (HS), Taylor Humphreys (HS), Brandon Satcher (HS)
2009: David Graves (HS), Corey Nielsen (HS), Cayman Shutter (HS)
2016: Dru Brown (JC), Cole Brownholz (JC), Cole McDonald (HS)
2000: Timmy Chang (HS), Kevin Gilbride (BYU Transfer), Nick Rolovich (JC)
2002: Inoke Funaki (HS), Ryan Stickler (HS), Jason Weildon (JC)
2004: Tyler Graunke (HS), Taylor Humphreys (HS), Brandon Satcher (HS)
2009: David Graves (HS), Corey Nielsen (HS), Cayman Shutter (HS)
2016: Dru Brown (JC), Cole Brownholz (JC), Cole McDonald (HS)
-
- Starter
- Posts: 749
- Joined: Sun Aug 10, 2008 6:22 pm
Re: Why a 1 and done QB might not be a bad idea
While I understand losing Dru Brown to transferring could bother some of us, I actually feel that we might have a fresh opportunity for a new start with Rolo's RNS Offense.
While I had hoped that we would have hired a QB Coach in Vince Passas as the 10th hire, our QB stable shouldn't be a concern if Rolo, Stutz and Coach Allen are dedicated to bringing UH back to one of the top passing teams in the country again.
Larry Tuileta could shake the rust off and has previous knowledge and potential in the RNS.
Chevan Cordeiro already understands the RNS.
Cole McDonald has seen some of the RNS with Rolo and if he can grasp the RNS this season, he gives UH a real Dual Threat concern for opposing defenses to worry about, if they blitz often.
Jeremy Moussa will have a new system to learn, but once he does, he has a very high upside potential.
Justin Uahinui, who Vince Passas holds in high regards, could be the surprise QB, not unlike Bryant Moniz.
While I had hoped that we would have hired a QB Coach in Vince Passas as the 10th hire, our QB stable shouldn't be a concern if Rolo, Stutz and Coach Allen are dedicated to bringing UH back to one of the top passing teams in the country again.
Larry Tuileta could shake the rust off and has previous knowledge and potential in the RNS.
Chevan Cordeiro already understands the RNS.
Cole McDonald has seen some of the RNS with Rolo and if he can grasp the RNS this season, he gives UH a real Dual Threat concern for opposing defenses to worry about, if they blitz often.
Jeremy Moussa will have a new system to learn, but once he does, he has a very high upside potential.
Justin Uahinui, who Vince Passas holds in high regards, could be the surprise QB, not unlike Bryant Moniz.